Healthcare Reform Principles That Cross Party Lines

 

Can both parties agree on anything in healthcare reform?

That was the question put to the test in a rare conversation between supporters and opponents of ObamaCare.

Lanhee J. Chen, fellow at the conservative Hoover Institute of Stanford University, and Ron Pollack, founding executive director of Families USA, writing in The Wall Street Journal summarized this rare meeting of conservative and liberal thinkers. Joining in the conversation were Sara Rosenbaum, Gail Wilensky, Joe Antos, John McDonough, Grace-Marie Turner and Stuart Butler – a group of health policy researchers who hold diverse political views and policy outlooks.

Principles They Agreed Upon

In the privacy of a conversation apart from the hysteria of media microphones and television cameras, this diverse group was able to elucidate those principles they agree should form the basis of healthcare reform. Here are the points they agreed should be present in any reform legislation:

  • Public subsidies for private insurance premiums should be means tested – This ensures that coverage will be more affordable for low-income people.
  • States should be given flexibility to streamline coverage options in Medicaid, CHIP, and other publicly supported insurance – This is to ensure that families can obtain the coverage that best suits their circumstances and serves their needs.
  • The existing tax exclusion for employer-sponsored health benefits should have reasonable limits
  • Subsidies should be provided for people who need help to purchase adequate insurance
  • States should be given waivers to reform Medicaid to develop fiscally sound and affordable coverage options.
  • States should be given greater authority to configure and redirect revenue streams from Medicaid, CHIP and private insurance to improve and strengthen coverage. Integration of funding streams would make it easier for individuals to keep the same coverage and providers when their employment or life circumstances change. Experimentation by the states would enable states to better serve the needs of their citizens.
  • Federal budget neutrality – Neutrality should be required for the cumulative budget impact of a proposal by the states.
  • State flexibility should not allow funds for healthcare services to be diverted to other purposes.

 

How well does the new Senate healthcare reform bill adhere to these principles?

The Better Care and Reconciliation Act of 2017 (BCRA) was just released by the Senate. Let’s see how well it stacks up with these bi-partisan principles:

  • Public subsidies for private insurance premiums should be means tested – The BCRA tax credits are means tested
  • States should be given flexibility to streamline coverage options in Medicaid, CHIP, and other publicly supported insurance – The BCRA gives states flexibility to develop their own Medicaid programs.
  • The existing tax exclusion for employer-sponsored health benefits should have reasonable limits – The BCRA maintains the “Cadillac tax” of ObamaCare that places limits on the employer tax exclusion.
  • Subsidies should be provided for people who need help to purchase adequate insurance – The BCRA provides this through means tested tax credits
  • States should be given waivers to reform Medicaid to develop fiscally sound and affordable coverage options – The BCRA eliminates the need for waivers, giving states the flexibility to reform Medicaid to their needs
  • States should be given greater authority to configure and redirect revenue streams from Medicaid, CHIP and private insurance to improve and strengthen coverage – The BCRA does this within the confines of long term per-capita caps
  • Federal budget neutrality – The BCRA places caps on Medicaid spending, eliminating the open-ended Medicaid entitlement of ObamaCare.
  • State flexibility should not allow funds for healthcare services to be diverted to other purposes – The BCRA includes this.

 

Therefore, the BCRA includes all eight recommended principles of this bi-partisan group of healthcare researchers. While both sides would prefer other changes or retained portions of ObamaCare, on these eight principles they agreed were essential, the BCRA includes every one!

This discussion makes it clear that there is bi-partisan agreement among healthcare researchers on the principles most needed in a new healthcare legislation.

If partisan politics could be put aside in the interest of the healthcare of the American people, both parties should be happy to vote for The Better Care and Reconciliation Act of 2017! What more can you hope for?

High Praise for the Senate Healthcare Bill

 

When the House passed the American Health Care Act (AHCA) there was lots of criticism from Democrats and even some Republicans. The healthcare economists had mixed reviews; some praised it, some didn’t. One of the critics was Avik Roy of The Manhattan Institute, who writes for Forbes.

Roy’s analysis of the AHCA was covered in an earlier post (How Good is the GOP Healthcare Plan?). His criticism was the flat tax credit in this bill rather than one that is means tested. Here is what he said then:

“That approach (flat tax credits) means that millions of low-income Americans in their fifties and sixties will be priced out of the insurance market, while millions of upper-income Americans who don’t need the help will get a big tax credit.”

“By repealing ObamaCare’s Medicaid expansion and replacing it with a flat tax credit that doesn’t provide enough assistance to the working poor, millions with incomes above the poverty line are going to lose their insurance.”

 

A Change of Tune

Now that the Senate has released its version of the bill, known as The Better Care Reconciliation Act of 2017 (BCRA), Roy is singing a different tune. In a post written for Forbes entitled “The New Senate Republican Bill Will Transform American Health Care”, Roy has this assessment:

“The hotly-anticipated Senate Republican health care bill came out on Thursday morning. The airwaves quickly filled up with predictable talking points from both sides. But once the dust settles, it will emerge that the Senate bill will have far-reaching effects on American health care; for the better.”

 

The difference is means testing of the tax credits. He says this solves the problems he described in his earlier criticism and also makes it easier to reform the Medicaid program. He explains:

“Because the Senate bill’s tax credits are robustly means-tested and available to those below the poverty line, the bill is able to repeal ObamaCare’s Medicaid expansion while offering higher-quality coverage to individuals who signed up for Medicaid under the expansion.”

 

Medicaid Reform

Besides lowering the cost of private insurance premiums, especially for low and moderate-income Americans, it makes significant improvements to Medicaid. Roy says this is accomplished in three ways:

  • Repeal of ObamaCare’s Medicaid expansion – replacing it with tax credits that allow low-income patients can buy private coverage at an affordable price.
  • State flexibility – allows states to check enrollment eligibility more frequently to remove those ineligible. Also encourages innovation in the states to lower costs and improve quality
  • Long term per-capita caps tied to inflation – to control the rising costs and make Medicaid fiscally sustainable for years to come.

 

His only real criticism of the Senate bill is that it doesn’t establish a waiting period for those who don’t sign up for insurance during the open enrollment. Lack of this waiting period encourages people to abuse the system by dropping in and out of coverage when they’re sick or healthy. Apparently this issue conflicted with Senate parliamentary rules and is yet to be worked out.

Despite this high praise for the Senate bill from this highly respected healthcare economist, expect Democrats to keep up their demagoguery to defeat the bill. Also, expect the CBO to say at least 18 million fewer Americans will be insured since this is their “baked-in” claim for any bill that repeals the Individual Mandate.

Some Republicans, too, continue to criticize this less-than perfect bill. As I write there are five Republican Senators holding out for improvements. Roy’s response to these Republicans puts this in perspective:

“But any Republican conservative in the Senate who is thinking of voting “no” on this bill: how many times in your life will you have the opportunity to vote for a bill that fundamentally transforms two entitlement programs? How often will you get to vote for a bill that cuts spending by hundreds of billions of dollars? How often will you get a chance to make a difference for millions of your constituents who are struggling under the weight of rising premiums and exploding deductibles?”

 

The time is now for healthcare reform. It’s time to get it done.

Republican Views Differ on Healthcare

 

Democrats and Republicans view healthcare differently. That’s not news. But there are also wide differences in how Republicans view healthcare, too.

Democrats seem to have the same point-of-view on healthcare. They all favor single-payer systems (see Single-Payer v. Market-Oriented Healthcare), or at least you don’t hear any other ideas coming from Congressional Democrats.

Republicans, on the other hand, are having trouble finding agreement among themselves. No one on the Republican side of the aisle is promoting single-payer systems, but there are wide differences in their ideas on how best to replace ObamaCare. This is the main problem facing Congressional Republicans who are trying to put forth new healthcare legislation they can agree on.

John C. Goodman, healthcare economist writing in Forbes, says there are three different schools of thought; “three parallel universes” he calls them. Here is his description of these three different universes:

Universe One: The Cafeteria Reformers

These Republicans want to “pick and choose” the things they like about ObamaCare and the things they don’t like and then retain the good while throwing out the bad. Don’t like a mandate? Throw it out. Want to retain coverage of pre-existing conditions? Just keep it as is. The problem with this approach is that these choices are not independent of one another.

For example, says Goodman, if insurers are not allowed to charge more for a pre-existing condition and people face no penalty for being uninsured, healthy people will stay uninsured until they get sick. Without these people in the marketplace, the price of insurance premiums will skyrocket for everyone else. This is already happening in the ObamaCare exchanges despite the mandates because the threat of consequences was low and the value of the insurance was also low.

If you don’t like the taxes of ObamaCare and repeal them without providing some other source of funding for the subsidies given to low-income Americans, these people will fall off the rolls of the insured. In part this is what happened in the CBO scoring of the AHCA, which predicted that the number of uninsured would rise with the new legislation. (There are other reasons the CBO got it wrong. See How Accurate is the CBO?)

According to Goodman, most of the Republicans in Congress belong in this universe of cafeteria reformers because they don’t really know much about health economics. But to be fair, neither do most of the Democrats.

Universe Two: The Luddite Reformers

The term “Luddite” refers to an Englishman, Ned Ludd, who reputedly smashed two stocking frames in 1779 in a vain attempt to prevent industrialization of the weaving industry. The Luddite Movement of 1811-1816 in Nottingham entrenched the term to mean “anyone who opposes automation, computerization, or technological advances in general.” In a broader sense it is resistance to change.

Goodman refers to the second universe as luddite reformers. Unlike the cafeteria reformers, the luddites understand the complexity of healthcare. They debate the merits of every policy proposal. If there is to be tax relief for people who buy their own insurance, what kind of tax relief? Should it be a deduction? Or a credit? Should it be refundable? Advanceable? Transferable? If people are not going to be allowed to game the system, what penalty should be faced by those who wait to insure until after they are sick?

These kinds of debates have been going on for decades. Although the luddite reformers is a small universe, nevertheless the debates can be vigorous. Refundable tax credits were in vogue during the HillaryCare debate in the 1990s. Then they rose again in the campaign of John McCain only to be disparaged by a vicious advertising campaign by Barack Obama that demagogued the issue. Now they are popular again in some conservative think tanks but not others.

Goodman calls them luddites because they see every problem through the lens of the past and every solution is drawn from the past. They are naturally resistant to any idea they haven’t heard several times before. He says they are universally committed to the managed competition model. Because of the similarity between the vision of ObamaCare and some of their proposals, disparagers of their thinking refer to them as “ObamaCare lite.”

Universe Three: The Visionary Reformers

Goodman says these people really believe in healthcare reform – and there are only three or four of them in Congress. (Needless to say, he identifies with this universe.) These people envision an ideal health care system and then ask how we can get there.

Goodman gives examples:

“In an ideal world people would choose between third-party insurance and individual self-insurance on a level playing field under the tax law. The appropriate amount of each should be determined by individual choice and competition in the marketplace, not by the tax writing committees of the Congress.”

“In an ideal world, chronic patients who manage their own care would be able to manage the money that pays for that care, without tax penalty. HSAs for the chronically ill is an idea I proposed many years ago and it has been a reality for home bound, disabled Medicaid patients for two decades or more. Yet, luddites can’t seem to grasp it – even though virtually every luddite health reform has called for a liberalization of HSAs.”

“In an ideal world, centers of excellence would specialize in the treatment of cancer, heart disease, AIDS, diabetes and other costly health conditions. They would reach out to patients with these conditions through print, broadcast and social media and in other ways. Instead of running away from the sick – with narrow networks and high out-of-pocket drug charges – the way plans in the ObamaCare exchanges are doing – these plans would compete for patients based on price, quality and access to care. To make that work we need a new type of risk adjustment, made possible by Health Status Insurance – something that would have happened naturally had the free market not been completely suppressed. Yet, this is a concept the luddites have never heard of.”

“In an ideal insurance system, group insurers (with 94% of the market) would not be allowed to dump their sickest, most costly enrollees onto non-group insurers (with 6% of the market).

“Finally, an ideal system does not trap low-income families into inferior health insurance with rationing by waiting (Medicaid). Instead, these families should be able to use their Medicaid dollars to buy into any plan available in the private marketplace. As their income rises and falls, and as eligibility comes and goes, there is no reason for anyone to be forcibly ejected from a plan that meets their needs.”

Goodman’s proposals include:

  • A new type of insurance – Limited Benefit Insurance
  • A new type of HSA – Roth HSAs
  • A new type of risk adjustment – Health Status Insurance
  • A new type of tax treatment for employer plans
  • Integrating Medicaid into the private insurance system
  • Protecting the individual market against unreasonable “dumping”

 

These proposals would move us much closer to an ideal healthcare system but unfortunately they are too new for the luddite reformers and too complicated for the cafeteria reformers to have any real chance of being incorporated into the new healthcare bill. But now you know why Republicans have so much trouble agreeing on the ObamaCare replacement!