Marriage Lengthens Life for Women

I have always thought marriage made for happier lives – at least in most cases. But I never realized it could mean longer lives.

A new study now reports that marriage is linked to significantly better physical and mental health – at least for women. Brendan Case and Ying Chen, writing in The Wall Street Journal, report a new study in the journal Global Epidemiology that makes this unexpected claim. They examined 11,830 American nurses, all women, who were initially never married, and compared those who got married between 1989 and 1993 with those who remined unmarried. They assess how their lives turned out on a wide range of important outcomes – including psychological well-being, health and longevity after about 25 years. The results may surprise you.

They say that in most cases they were able to control for the nurses’ well-being and health in 1989, before any of them had gotten married, as well as for a host of other relevant factors, such as age, race and socioeconomic status. This helped them rule out the possibility that, for example, happiness predicted marriage rather than being predicted by it, or that both happiness and marriage might be predicted by some hidden third factor.

They admit their findings were striking. The women who got married in the initial time frame, including those who subsequently divorced, had a 35% lower risk of death for any reason for the follow-up period than those who did not marry in that period. Compared to those who didn’t marry, the married women also had lower risk of cardiovascular disease, less depression and loneliness, were happier and more optimistic, and had a greater sense of purpose and hope.

They also examined the effects of staying married versus becoming divorced. Among those who were already married at the start of the study, divorce was associated with consistently worse subsequent health and well-being, including greater loneliness and depression, and lower levels of social integration. There was also somewhat less robust evidence that women who divorced had a 19% higher risk of death for any reason over the 25 years of follow-up than those who stayed married. Given how many factors influence health and well-being (genes, diet, exercise, environment, social network, etc.), the fact that marriage could reduce 25-year mortality by more than a third – and that divorce could possibly increase it by nearly a fifth – indicates how important it remains even for modern life.

There are limitations of this study. The study sample was mostly white and relatively well-off professional women deciding about marriage in the early 1990s. The study tells us nothing about the effects of marriage on men. The authors acknowledge these limitations. They say, “Nonetheless, our study’s focus on women offers important insights in view of the continuing hold of feminist critiques of marriage as an instrument of patriarchal domination. Other things being equal (and of course in particular cases they often aren’t), marriage – with the support, companionship and affection it offers – is still a crucial constituent of a flourishing life for many women.”

They also express concerns for new generations, such as Gen-Xers, who seem to live by different social standards. In the past 30 years, norms against extramarital cohabitation have relaxed considerably. As recently as 2001, Gallup found that only 53% of Americans thought sex outside of marriage was morally acceptable, but by 2021 that figure was 76%. The impact these changes in attitudes will have on marriage are undetermined at this time, but the authors say recent research has typically found that unmarried cohabiting couples report less happiness and relationship stability than do married couples.

This is no surprise for students of the Bible, who understand that marriage is an institution created by God for the procreation of mankind and the fulfillment of men and women. That research now confirms that women are happier and live longer when married is only confirming that what God created is a good thing, intended for mankind’s benefit. But the declining appreciation of that fact in our modern culture bodes poorly for our future.

Biden’s Medicare Hypocrisy

President Joe Biden recently attacked Republicans for allegedly threatening to make plans to decimate Medicare. He said in his recent State of the Union address, “If anyone tries to cut Medicare, I will stop them.” This false accusation makes good political theater, but everyone knows Republicans have no intent on decimating Medicare. However, they are concerned enough about the future of Medicare to want to discuss ways to ensure its solvency.

We’ve been talking about Medicare’s future in recent posts. The Medicare board of trustees says that Medicare will be insolvent in six years if changes aren’t made soon. Seema Verma, the former director of CMS under President Trump, made some suggestions to solve the problem (The Medicare Status Quo Can’t Last) and I have made some comments on her ideas and suggestions of my own (Solving Medicare/Medicaid Insolvency).

Senator James Lankford has introduced a bill in Congress to address the problem by making it possible for physicians to own hospitals again, a prohibition under the Affordable Care Act (Doctor-Owned Hospitals). This bill would encourage physicians to own and operate for-profit hospitals, which have been shown to increase quality and lower costs in Medicare patients.

All of these ideas have merit and should be promoted. But the biggest threat to Medicare isn’t actually Republicans; it’s Joe Biden himself. That’s not my opinion, but the opinion of Grace Marie Turner writing for Galen.org. She says Biden has a long record of making deep cuts in Medicare. She gives several examples to support her claims:

  • The Biden administration proposed on Feb. 1 “payment regulations” impacting the popular Medicare Advantage plans where 30 million seniors get their coverage. The proposal affects the higher risk adjustment payments that MA plans get for sicker seniors to cover their more expensive care, as Doug Holtz-Eakin of the American Action Forum explains.
  • A study released by the Better Medicare Alliance showed the administration’s plans would mean a “$540 decrease in benefits per member per year,” or a “Medicare cut” of $150 billionover 10 years.
  • Only six months ago, Mr. Biden spearheaded passage of the Inflation Reduction Act that the CBO calculates decreases Medicare spending by $307 billion to finance a slew of initiatives, including hiring 87,000 new IRS agents.  The cuts already are causing drug companies to halt research on promising new treatments. “The bill would reduce drug industry research and development by about $663 billion,resulting in 135 fewer new medicines. This will amount to a loss of 330 million life-years, about 30 times the loss from COVID-19 so far,” according to Prof. Tomas Philipson of the University of Chicago.  So much for seniors’ quality of life, as Sally Pipes explains.
  • And this is after Biden voted in 2010 to cut $716 billion from Medicare to finance Obamacare subsidies. The Manhattan Institute’s Chris Pope details the history of how cutting Medicare repeatedly is used as a piggy bank to pay for other spending.

 

She says Medicare Advantage definitely needs modernizing but in a thoughtful, data-driven way, as AEI’s Dr. Brian Miller, economist Steve Parente, and former Medicare and Medicaid director Gail Wilensky explain. Heritage’s Bob Moffit writes that Medicare Advantage should be the basis for overall Medicare modernization after demonstrating that seniors enrolled in MA plans during Covid had “fewer hospitalizations, fewer deaths, and a greater ability to receive treatment for routine medical conditions.”

(For links to these other commentators, see her newsletter at Galen.org.)

Everyone wants Medicare to survive and prosper in the future. Anyone who claims their political opponents want to cut Medicare is lying to the American people; perhaps to cover their own sins.

Doctor-Owned Hospitals

What if lawyers weren’t allowed to own law firms or chefs weren’t allowed to own restaurants? Why not, you might ask? But doctors aren’t allowed to own hospitals.

This is the question posed by Senator James Lankford (R-Oklahoma) and Brian J. Miller (Professor of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University) in a recent Op-ed published in The Wall Street Journal. Most people don’t know that a tiny paragraph in the enormous Affordable Care Act (ObamaCare) prohibits physicians from building or owning hospitals. Any physician-owned hospital built before 2010 is grandfathered in, but is prohibited from growing beyond the size it was when the bill passed. What sense does that make?

This law limits competition, which always promotes quality and lower prices. Isn’t that a good thing? The law defies common sense and is surely contributing to higher prices for Medicare and reduced access to treatment for millions of Americans.

Recently, I discussed the financial problems of Medicare and some ideas to solve this problem (Solving Medicare/Medicaid Insolvency). Today, we are discussing yet another way to lower the costs of Medicare and solve the insolvency problem. According to the Medicare board of trustees, we have only about six years left to solve this problem. By 2030, Medicare and Medicaid will be the largest contributors to the national debt.

The authors say the current political debate has focused on the effects of monopoly power and consolidation across industries, including healthcare. The Biden administration’s executive order on competition specifically mentions hospital consolidation and subsequent rising costs. Yet political leaders overlook the most obvious way to increase healthcare options: letting doctor-owned and managed facilities grow as they did before 2010.

Naturally, the hospital industry opposes doctors owning hospitals. They don’t like the competition. They argue that physicians cherry-pick health patients and prefer those with private insurance as a rationale for supporting the ban on physician-owned hospitals. In response to these concerns, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) in 2007 added an adjustment to hospital payments for sicker patients. Other research shows that physician-owned hospitals had no difference in the number of Medicaid patients compared with hospitals not owned by physicians.

This is not a new issue; just one that needs reconsideration. I first wrote about this problem in a blog post 11/26/15 called Physician-Owned Hospitals Deliver Quality and Value. This post was later published in my recent book, Changing Healthcare. I said then that banning new or expanding existing physician-owned hospitals makes sense only if you want higher-cost, lower-quality healthcare.

Why does the ACA ban new construction of physician-owned hospitals?

The ACA was developed in close cooperation with the major stakeholders in the healthcare industry. That means hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, and healthcare insurers. The hospital associations are dominated by large non-profit general hospitals that must compete with smaller physician-owned hospitals (POHs). They successfully lobbied the Obama administration into punishing the POHs that violate the new construction ban by prohibiting their participation in Medicare and Medicaid. In other words, the ban is based on politics, not on lowering the costs of Medicare and Medicaid or providing access to healthcare.

At the time, the hospital industry claims that POHs provided higher cost, selective care went unchallenged. But since that time, research has shown a different story. Here are some revealing new statistics:

  • Seven of the top 10 hospitals receiving quality bonuses in the Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Program in 2015 were POHs.
  • The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) released Star Ratings in 2015 based on consumer assessment survey. More than 40% of POHs received the top 5-star rating compared to only 5% of general hospitals.
  • The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) found that patients are 3 to 5 times more likely to experience complications at general hospitals than at physician-owned hospitals.

These statistics clearly establish that POHs are providing high-quality healthcare.

But what about the cost? How do the POHs compare to the non-profit hospitals?

An analysis by Avalon Health Economics said that POHs are saving Medicare $3.2 billion over 10 years. For that reason alone, you would expect the federal government to want more, not less, of these hospitals.

Furthermore, in contrast to claims by the general hospitals, POHs provide more charity care, not less. A CMS study found that POHs spend nearly 6% of their total revenue on community benefits compared to less than 1% for other hospitals. In addition, a major study was published in The British Medical Journal that found patients at POHs and non-POHs were equally likely to have Medicaid insurance and to be from racial or ethnic minority groups. The study concluded: “POHs also performed equally to non-POHs on a wide array of measures of quality of care, costs, and payments for care.”

With this much evidence to support POHs, including high-quality care and cost-lowering measures, what is standing in the way of reform? The answer is crony capitalism – government picking winners and losers based on political support. To reverse this bad decision will take political courage. Senator Lankford is introducing the Patient Access to Higher Quality Health Care Act to solve the problem. This legislation would put patient choice back into hospital markets by allowing doctors to build efficient businesses and better serve patients. Competition always raises quality and lowers costs – and we need that in healthcare if we’re going to solve the insolvency of Medicare and Medicaid.