Long Covid – Real or Myth? – Part II

We’re discussing a condition called “long Covid” and wondering if it is real or not. In Part I we talked about the opinion of a psychiatrist who believes this is not a real condition, but instead a misdiagnosis of those with anxiety and depression or physical conditions unrelated to Covid infection.

I also likened this situation to another vague condition, called fibromyalgia. Both are poorly understood conditions with little or no way to make a certain diagnosis. Fibromyalgia has long been diagnosed without any available accurate diagnostic tests, but recently there has been developed a blood test with possibly 70% correlation. In both conditions, there is a high incidence of anxiety and depression.

Unfortunately, getting to the truth is hampered by the social and political implications of each diagnosis. Fibromyalgia is often diagnosed rather than anxiety and depression because it is more socially acceptable. Long Covid may be diagnosed more often in those who wish to make political statements concerning pandemic treatments.

The evidence of this latter possibility is discussed in a recent article published in The Wall Street Journal by Allysia Finley. She is alarmed at the conclusions being touted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) after a recent study that claims to find that nearly 36% of Covid cases among student, faculty and staff at George Washington University resulted in “long Covid.” The study suggests that young, healthy people face a high risk of chronic debilitating symptoms after infection despite being at low risk of getting severely ill with the virus.

The study also finds that the unvaccinated were at more than twice as high a risk of developing long Covid as those fully vaccinated who had gotten boosters. While this may seem logical, a closer inspection reveals there is little evidence to support those conclusions.

Like many colleges, GWU held classes online during the first year of the pandemic even as some students returned to campus. Those on campus were required to undergo weekly Covid testing. During the 2021-22 school year, classrooms reopened but students were required to be vaccinated and later boosted. The college recorded 4,800 Covid cases between August 2020 and February 2022. Those who tested positive were later asked to complete 15-to-20-minute surveys about their health and behavioral changes. Only one-third completed the surveys and those who did might have been more likely to report lingering health problems – a phenomenon in research known as nonresponse bias.

Finley says the study has two other major methodological problems. First, it doesn’t include a control group of students and faculty that weren’t infected. The finding that nearly 36% reported long Covid symptoms is meaningless without such a sample to determine how common such symptoms were among people who never had Covid.

Second, as I said earlier, “long Covid” is poorly defined, but the study defines it expansively to include problems common among college students – difficulty making decisions, fatigue, anxiety, sadness, trouble sleeping and the catch-all phrase “other symptoms.” If a student reported at least one physical or psychological problem, he was classified as having long Covid. (By this definition, I am surprised the incidence of “long Covid” wasn’t higher!)

A CDC survey in January 2021 reported that 57% of respondents between 18 and 29 had experienced anxiety or depression within the previous seven days. This survey included both those with and without Covid. The well-reported uptick in mental health problems among young people during the pandemic was in part caused by government lockdowns and virtual learning policies such as at colleges like GWU.

Finley says, “It’s impossible to determine from the study whether any GWU students actually developed long Covid, let alone whether vaccines and boosters reduce risk for the ill-defined syndrome.” (Remember, there is no definitive way to make this diagnosis.) Nonetheless, the study says its findings reinforce the need to “advocate and monitor for vaccine and booster adherence to published recommendation.” That sounds like a political, rather than a scientific, conclusion. This study is clearly being used by the CDC to justify their policies and recommendations.

None of this really answers the question of whether or not “long Covid” is real. A November 2021 study reported in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) found that many people with persistent physical symptoms that are commonly ascribed to long Covid didn’t actually test positive for antibodies! In other words, a belief that one had Covid was more strongly associated with physical symptoms than a lab-confirmed infection. Evidently, many people are simply looking for an excuse for their complaints which is socially, and perhaps politically, acceptable.

Lastly, Finley raises any interesting question – How did lockdowns and school shutdowns contribute to putative long Covid symptoms? A JAMA study last September found that depression, anxiety, perceived stress, loneliness and worry about Covid were tied to a 1.3 – 1.5 -fold increased risk of self-reported postviral symptoms as well as increased risk of daily life impairment. In other words, is the increased reporting of such symptoms a result of long Covid or the result of the mental stress of the pandemic itself?

She concludes with this concern: “By exaggerating the incidence of long Covid among young, healthy adults, the CDC deflects attention from mental-health problems caused by misconceived pandemic policies. It also fuels public distrust in the scientific enterprise, which may prove to be the pandemic’s most destructive long-term effect.”

Long Covid – Real or Myth? – Part I

For quite some time, since the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020, there has been a debate in the medical community and the media about post-Covid symptoms now referred to as “long Covid.” Is there really such a condition and, if so, how prevalent is it?

Nearly two years ago I published a post based upon an article written by Dr. Jeremy Devine, a psychiatry resident at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, called Fake Science Behind Long Covid Symptoms. At that time there was very little known about this condition, but reports were becoming more frequent. Dr. Devine said there is no scientific basis for this condition. Yet, the National Institutes of Health announced then a $1.15 billion initiative to research the “prolonged health consequences” of Covid-19 infection.

Dr. Devine acknowledged that some elderly patients, with co-morbidities, do experience symptoms that outlast the coronavirus infection. But, as a psychiatrist, he notes that such symptoms can also be psychologically generated or caused by a physical illness unrelated to the prior infection. He says “long Covid” is largely an invention of vocal patient activist groups. Legitimizing it with generous funding risks worsening the symptoms the NIH is hoping to treat.

He based his opinions on shoddy research supported by NIH Director Francis Collins, who has ties to activist groups promoting this condition. Dr. Collins has since lost some of his credibility when it was revealed he and Dr. Anthony Fauci colluded to prevent any investigation of the origins of the Covid-19 pandemic that might look closer at the Wuhan, China laboratories, which received financial support from NIH.

Why would a scientific institution, such as NIH, support unscientific conclusions?

Dr. Devine opines that this subjugation of scientific rigor to preconceived belief reflects a common dynamic encountered in clinical practice. He says, “Patients who struggle with chronic and vague symptoms often vehemently reject a physician’s diagnosis that suggests an underlying mental health issue, in part because of the stigma around mental illness and the false belief that psychologically generated symptoms aren’t “real.”

The problem is there is no known way to positively identify “long Covid.” There is no laboratory test or imaging study that can confirm this diagnosis. The list of symptoms generally associated with “long Covid” include fatigue, “brain fog”, and other vague aches and pains. These same symptoms are also associated with chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, anxiety and depression.

When I began medical school nearly 50 years ago, fibromyalgia was a new diagnosis. Very little was known about it then and very little more is known about it now. Like “long Covid”, there was no laboratory test or imaging study that could confirm the diagnosis. According to the National Institutes of Health, “Fibromyalgia is a chronic disorder that causes pain and tenderness throughout the body, as well as fatigue and trouble sleeping.” Patients with fibromyalgia are considered hyper-sensitive to pain. There is a high correlation between patients diagnosed with fibromyalgia and those diagnosed with anxiety and depression.

Today, there is a laboratory blood test that can be used to determine if a patient has fibromyalgia. But the test has only about 70% accuracy according to the American College of Rheumatology. A patient must have pain in at least four of five regions; symptoms have to be present for at least three months, widespread pain index score must be >7 and symptom severity scale score is >5 or widespread pain index score is 4 to 6 and symptom severity score is >9.

Even if there really is a condition called fibromyalgia, there is great pressure on physicians to make this diagnosis instead of attributing their symptoms to anxiety and depression. The population most associated with fibromyalgia is middle-aged women (some studies say 90%) and the same population is also associated with a high incidence of anxiety and depression. Since fibromyalgia is a more culturally accepted diagnosis than anxiety and depression, many women prefer this diagnosis – and pressure their doctors to agree.

All of this brings me back to “long Covid.” Is it real, or is it a more acceptable diagnosis than anxiety and depression? At this point we don’t really know, but there is certainly pressure to make this diagnosis for many reasons.

 

(To learn more about this subject, stay tuned to my next post.”)

Covid Lab Leak Likely

More than three years later, the truth is finally emerging, slowly. Like the dross impurities that rise to the surface in the refinement of gold, the lies are surfacing as the heat of the furnace turns up. This heat is the result of the change of power that the mid-term elections determined, with Republicans regaining control of the House of Representatives.

The U.S. Department of Energy has just released a report that concludes that the Covid-19 virus likely leaked from a lab in Wuhan, China. The case is not described as definitive, but it is more evidence that the media and public-health groupthink about Covid was mistaken and destructive, according to the editorial board of The Wall Street Journal.

They say the salient detail is that DOE’s judgment is based on “new” but still secret intelligence. Yet DOE’s new judgment is nonetheless made with “low confidence.” The FBI has also concluded that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was the “most likely” origin of the virus, but other U.S. intelligence agencies either don’t believe they have enough evidence or believe it had a natural origin. That’s two U.S. agencies, DOE and the FBI, that have come forth to acknowledge the lab leak is the explanation that makes the most sense.

Naturally, Dr. Anthony Fauci still clings to his claim that the virus originated in a “wet market.” The White House also won’t acknowledge this additional evidence that points toward a lab leak of the virus. With this weak response, and the weak response to the Chinese spy balloon, it’s becoming very evident that President Joe Biden cannot be trusted to hold China accountable for anything. The only reason there is any doubt left is that China has done everything possible to hide their responsibility, blaming the virus pandemic on a natural origin. But the old saying is, “If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck, it’s probably a duck.” Why would anyone be skeptical of a determination that a virus that emerged from Wuhan, China, probably came from a Wuhan China laboratory studying the same virus?

Comedian Jon Stewart said it well; “If an outbreak of chocolaty goodness was discovered in Hershey, Pennsylvania, would anyone doubt it came from the Hershey chocolate factory? If a novel coronavirus is discovered in Wuhan, China, home of the Wuhan Novel Coronavirus Lab, would anyone doubt it came from the Wuhan virus laboratory?”

Yet anyone who suggested such a logical conclusion in 2020 was vilified by the media. On April 22, 2020, WSJpublished an Op-ed by Arkansas Senator Tom Cotton that pointed to the possibility of the lab leak and raised doubts about Beijing’s claim that it had originated in an animal “wet market.” The media conformity caucus immediately derided Mr. Cotton for peddling a “conspiracy theory” that had been “debunked,” as the Washington Post put it at the time. Former CDC director Dr. Robert Redfield also favored the lab leak theory, but was called a racist and received death threats for daring to disagree with the prevailing theory.

We have since learned that public-health officials wanted to hide that U.S. financial aid to the Wuhan lab from the National Institute of Health (NIH) may have contributed to the “gain-of-function” research that could have led to the leak. We know from emails released that NIH director Dr. Francis Collins and NIAID director Dr. Anthony Fauci colluded to obfuscate the research they were supporting by coordinating the scientific community response that denounced the lab leak theory. The main stream media were happy to promote this disinformation.

The WJS editors conclude: “Because of China’s refusal to cooperate in the investigation, we may never know with certainty how the virus emerged. But Americans deserve to know the facts about the relationship of the U.S. National Institutes of Health to the Wuhan lab and to promoting gain-of-function research. The early deception also needs to be exposed.”

Republicans are calling for President Biden to declassify all intelligence on this issue immediately, instead of letting it dribble out in half-hearted spurts. But Biden’s cozy relationship with the Chinese makes it unlikely he will do anything to embarrass the Chinese Communist Party.